Assess Retail Store Experience with a Mystery Shopper Audit [2024]

August 9, 2024
Digital Transformation
Retail Operations

The customer's perception is your reality.

Kate Zabriskie

Offering a first-rate in-store experience is neither optional nor a differentiator. Consumers today expect more from their shopping experiences. Meeting these expectations is table stakes to win.

But how can you find out whether the visitor and shopper experience in your retail store is truly working? Sure, Google and social media reviews and ratings help. But, reacting to poor reviews is not much of a strategy.

This blog will discuss various approaches store owners and brands can use to evaluate the visitor experience using Mystery Shopper Audits, a potent tool for obtaining organized, objective feedback that can help discover and resolve possible issues in your business's shopping experience.

The Retail Store Experience

In 2023, online shopping revenue reached a staggering $5.78 trillion worldwide, with projections indicating it will surpass $12.2 trillion by 2030. As online commerce grows, some of that growth will come at the cost of the physical store.

As the pie shrinks, the brands that offer the very best retail store experience have an edge.

From the time a shopper walks in until they depart, the total of all interactions they have with your store is their retail store experience. This includes the ambiance, product placement, customer service, navigability, checkout procedure, and even post-purchase interactions.

A fantastic retail experience can lead to greater consumer happiness, more sales, and stronger brand loyalty. Conversely, a disappointing experience can lead to negative word-of-mouth, lost sales, and a tarnished brand. Consequently, it is imperative to assess and enhance your store's experience routinely.

Methods to Assess Your Retail Store Experience

Consider the following to evaluate the retail experience and make any necessary changes:

1. Revenue Figures

Revenue numbers are probably the most direct indicator of your retail store's experience. Growing unit revenue is usually the best indicator of market demand and customer satisfaction with their shopping experience and willingness to spend more. On the other hand, reduced growth can point to problems requiring attention.

Though they offer insight, revenue shouldn't be the only measure of how well your store performs. Revenue does not reveal the nuances of the consumer experience, such as how consumers view their interactions with staff or the simplicity with which they find things.

2. Footfall Analysis

Tracking the number of individuals who visit your store over a specified period is the basis of footfall analysis.

Although high footfall suggests your store is drawing business, it does not always guarantee people are making purchases or having a favorable experience.

By helping you pinpoint peak shopping times, footfall pattern analysis helps you maximize personnel numbers and guarantee that consumers get the best possible service at crowded times.

Further, by matching footfall statistics with sales data, you may ascertain the conversion rate—that is, the proportion of visitors who buy. A low conversion rate would point to problems with customer service, retail layout, or product demand.

3. Feedback from Staff

Statistics may sometimes obfuscate the most nuanced and material insights. The best way to ensure you are capturing them is by talking to the frontline staff.

Every day, your staff deal with shoppers on the front lines. They can offer nuanced takes about the shopper experience that quantitative statistics might miss.

Frequent staff input will enable you to spot typical customer concerns, frequently asked questions, and possible areas for improvement. Sometimes, it could be something as simple as making info-cards available on products (material, warranty period, payment plans, etc.).

Promoting honest communication with your staff not only enables you to get pertinent data but also encourages staff responsibility and ownership. Employees who perceive their ideas as valued are more inclined to engage and strive to provide exceptional service.

4. Customer Surveys and Feedback

Direct client feedback is one of the best approaches to evaluating the retail store experience.

Whether done in-person or by email or SMS surveys, probe consumers about different facets of their experience, including product availability, store layout, staff friendliness, pricing, and general level of happiness.

Customer comments may provide specific insights on areas that require improvement and those that perform well. For instance, if several patrons have trouble locating items, it could be time to review your store's design or signage.

5. Social Media and Online Reviews

Online reviews and social media play a significant role in defining how people view your store in the digital age. Google Reviews and social media listings help you get a near real-time picture of consumer impressions of your business.

While critical comments can identify areas where you might be lacking, positive reviews and social media mentions help confirm that you are on the right path. Responding to both positive and negative internet reviews demonstrates your appreciation for consumer feedback and your desire to continually improve.

Go beyond star ratings and into subjective comments from online reviews to uncover specific aspects that need improvement.

6. Competition Analysis and Benchmarking

Benchmarking your store's performance against similar businesses or local competitors provides valuable context for your evaluations.

Assessing metrics like foot traffic, conversion rates, and revenue in comparison to industry standards and local rivals helps identify areas for improvement and highlights your strengths.

For instance, if a nearby store consistently draws more foot traffic, it may be worth examining its strategies, such as hosting events, offering promotions, or enhancing the store's visual appeal.

Mystery Shopper Audits to Assess Retail Store Experience

Hiring a qualified evaluator—known as a mystery shopper—to visit your store and objectively evaluate the customer experience is the foundation of a mystery shopper audit. Regular consumers subconsciously assess many facets of the shopping experience, such as store cleanliness, product availability, staff interactions, and checkout efficiency. Mystery shoppers follow a methodical and process driven approach to capture as many facets of the experience as possible.

The main benefit of a mystery shopper audits is that it provides a third-party, objective perspective on your store's performance.

Mystery shoppers offer organized feedback, unlike regular consumers, who might not offer comments unless they have had an especially good or negative experience.

How Mystery Shopper Audits Work

Usually, a mystery shopper audit consists of multiple phases:

  1. Defining the Objectives: Clear alignment on the audit's objectives will help you decide what you want to evaluate. This can cover particular aspects such as customer service, product knowledge, store layout, or general shopping experience. The goals must align with your company objectives, and where you really want insight for that particular audit.
  2. Select your Mystery Shopping Audit Partner: While you may be able to source your own mystery shoppers and work with them, it is better to outsource the activity to specialist mystery shopper agencies. Agencies have a ready pool of shoppers across a variety of demographics, which enables them to find best fit shoppers quickly and at scale. Agencies are also particularly useful if you want to perform frequent audits. But, if you want to run it yourself, you can always find candidates on gig platforms like Upwork or Fiverr. You can post and solicit applications through your social channels.
  3. Developing the Evaluation Criteria: Working with the mystery shopping firm, you will create a set of evaluation criteria depending on the goals. These standards should be specific, quantifiable, and tailored to your store's unique needs. For instance, if one of your criteria is the quality of staff interactions, the myster shopper audit criteria can specifically evaluate aspects like welcoming shoppers, answering queries, and offering help.
  4. Selecting the Mystery Shoppers: Choose the mystery shoppers depending on demographic criteria that fit your usual clientele. This guarantees that the comments are pertinent and capture the experience of your target market.
  5. Conducting the Audit: The mystery shopper visits your business and assesses the experience using the pre-defined criteria. To get a complete picture of the store's performance, they might visit several times throughout the week or at different times of day.
  6. Reporting the Findings: Following the audit, mystery shoppers provide a thorough report with observations and assessments. This will show both advantages and drawbacks, offering practical analysis of areas that need work.

Benefits of Mystery Shopper Audits

Conducting a mystery shopper audit has the following benefits:

  • Objective Feedback: Mystery shoppers offer objective, consistent assessments based on pre-defined criteria, unlike ordinary consumer feedback, which can be subjective and impacted by personal preferences.
  • Uncover Hidden Issues: Mystery shopper audits help find hidden problems that might not be immediately obvious using other evaluation techniques. For instance, a mystery shopper can find that your employees are not actively interacting with consumers or providing help, even if they claim to be doing great customer service.
  • Benchmark Performance: Regular mystery shopper audits allow you to benchmark your store's performance over time. This helps you to monitor development, spot recurring problems, and guarantee that your store regularly offers a first-rate buying environment.
  • Employee Training and Development: Mystery Shopper Audit comments can help guide staff development initiatives. If the audit finds, for instance, that staff members lack product knowledge, you can carve out focused training to close this disparity. This increases employee confidence and performance in addition to the consumer experience.
  • Customer Experience: Solving the problems found in a Mystery Shopper Audit will help to improve the whole shopping experience, raising your chances of retaining consumers and consistently landing 5-star reviews. Customers who feel appreciated and have a good experience are more likely to come back and tell others about your store.

Clearly, Mystery Shopper Audits can help you find hidden problems, measure performance, and make educated decisions to improve the shopping experience by offering objective, disciplined comments from a third-party perspective.

Including Mystery Shopper Audits in your evaluation plan will help you, regardless of size—small boutique or large retail chain—increase customer happiness, sales, and long-term profitability.

Remember that the secret to a good retail store experience is not just drawing consumers with great marketing but also making sure they have an enjoyable, unforgettable experience. Regular evaluation and improvement of your store's experience is the best way to do that.

Take your retail operations to the next level with Hubler's retail operations software.

Procure to Pay
A solution that simplifies your complex workflows.
Lease management
Your one-stop shop for everything lease management.
Asset management
Asset Management Solution that adapts to your business.
Expense management
Manage your expenses your way
Hubler-get-a-demo

Get a demo!

Please submit your details and our Product Consultant will connect with you to understand your needs.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
hubler-close-btn